that recess seems like an inelegant and partial solution to a problem that already has a better solution.
Agreed. I don't like the way it looks. I don't mind regular cleats, if they're properly installed where you can't trip on them, I don't see what the issue is with them.
Like this one here, it's under the bow rails, so I don't see the whole point of making a recess area for it? I can't see why anyone would be walking there?
The whole recess makes it look stranger than a simple surface mounted cleat would, IMO. Or if for some reason (?) this bothered them too much, do a pop-up cleat.